ILR Bulletin, Vol 2005, Issue 9
16 June 2005

Print this page

CLJ Law MALAYSIA
http://www.cljlaw.com


Introduction:
To get the most out of this law bulletin join CLJ Law Online now - http://www.cljlaw.com/registration.asp
Feel free to forward this to your colleagues. Get this bulletin as email by going to http://www.cljlaw.com/ilrsubscribefrm.asp


INDUSTRIAL LAW  REPORTS ISSUE 1 of 2005

Message From The President

Cases Contested

943/2004 Institut Seni Lukis Sabah v. Lee Nee Ping [2005] 1 ILR 227
(Industrial Court - Jurisdiction)

1129/2004 Singer (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd v. R Somasundaram V Ramasamy [2005] 1 ILR 1
(Misconduct - Misuse Of Authority)

1181/2004 Nation-Tech Sdn Bhd v. Noor Hazman Kamal [2005] 1 ILR 13
(Termination Of Services - Summary Dismissal)

1182/2004 Arah Sukma Sdn Bhd lwn. Clarence Edward Nonis [2005] 1 ILR 24
(Pembuangan Kerja Konstruktif - Salah Laku Dan Prestasi Pekerja)

1183/2004 Singamip Industry Sdn Bhd lwn. Ng Khee Siong [2005] 1 ILR 34
(‘Pekerja’ - Status Pekerja)

1191/2004 Abbott Laboratories (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd v. Yeoh Siew Tin [2005] 1 ILR 43
(Constructive Dismissal - Use Of Vulgar Words And Threats)

1319/2004 Suechi Industries Sdn Bhd v. Umah Jeralene Louis Adaikalasami [2005] 1 ILR 54
(Constructive Dismissal - Gross Fraudulent Misconduct)

1333/2004 Heap Loong Poultry Farm Sdn Bhd v. Tan Ah Bah [2005] 1 ILR 70
(Industrial Court Procedure - Trial)

1345/2004 Shangri-La’s Rasa Sayang Resort v. Arman Aliyas [2005] 1 ILR 76
(Misconduct - Dishonesty)

1354/2004 Rocon Equipment Sdn Bhd & Anor v. Zainudin Muhamad Salleh & Yang Lain [2005] 1 ILR 213
(Retrenchment - Redundancy)

1364/2004 Indah Water Konsortium Sdn Bhd v. Jasuaih Bobby & Anor [2005] 1 ILR 84
(Misconduct - Participating In Unauthorised Work)

1382/2004 Darmawatti Dahari v. Malaysia Mining Corporation Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 93
(Constructive Dismissal - Victimisation)

1385/2004 Tawada Paper Industries (M) Sdn Bhd v. Goh Beng Ghee [2005] 1 ILR 109
(Industrial Court Procedure - Amendment To Statement In Reply)

1439/2004 Dynacraft Industries Sdn Bhd v. Teow Sian Keong [2005] 1 ILR 115
(Resignation - Forced Resignation)

1684/2004 Bengkel Tenaga Kenderaan v. Chok Yun Loi [2005] 1 ILR 128
(Termination Of Services - Financial Hardship)

1901/2004 Leo Burnett Advertising Sdn Bhd v. Teh Bee Bee [2005] 1 ILR 141
(Misconduct - Habitual Late Coming)

9/2005 Penerbangan Malaysia Bhd (Mas) v. Zainudin Mohd Nor [2005] 1 ILR 147
(Absenteeism - Absence Without Leave)

11/2004 Plusnet Communication Sdn Bhd & Ors v. Leong Lai Peng (F) & Anor [2005] 1 ILR 155
(Retrenchment - Redundancy)

69/2005 Chi Yuan Metal Industry (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd v. Metal Industry Employees Union [2005] 1 ILR 167
(Non-Compliance - Collective Agreement)

85/2005 Keretapi Tanah Melayu Bhd v. Sateman Pawit [2005] 1 ILR 172
(Breach Of Company Policies - Punishment)

94/2005 Chung Sen Transportation v. Johnny Rinip [2005] 1 ILR 184
(Industrial Court Procedure - Service)

95/2005 Puranachandran v. HSS Intergrated Sdn Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 195
(Retrenchment - Company Restructuring)

Cases Amicably Settled, Consented And/Or Undisputed And/Or Struck Off

972/2004 Coral Island Cruises Tour & Travel Sdn Bhd v. Chan Man Yuen [2005] 1 ILR 262

983/2004 American Express (M) Sdn Bhd & Anor v. Uma Naga [2005] 1 ILR 262

1041/2004 Yeung Lok Coldstorage Sdn Bhd v. Awang Zulkipli Awang Ojey [2005] 1 ILR 262

1079/2004 Seni Kembara Construction Sdn Bhd lwn. Mohamed Taufiq Abdul Rahman [2005] 1 ILR 262

1090/2004 Sutera Habour Golf & Country Club v. Abdul Amat Nawi [2005] 1 ILR 262

1108/2004 Castlefield (Klang) Rubber Estates Plc lwn. Abdul Kadir EK Kunja Ahmad [2005] 1 ILR 262

1114/2004 Belleview Property Management Sdn Bhd lwn. Daniel Peh Soon Teik [2005] 1 ILR 262

1175/2004 Perwik Sdn Bhd v. Lee Vhew [2005] 1 ILR 262

1219/2004 Syarikat Wira Jaya v. Mary Langit [2005] 1 ILR 262

1277/2004 Exxonmobil Exploration And Production Malaysia Inc v. Kesatuan Pekerja-pekerja Exploration And Production Malaysia Inc [2005] 1 ILR 262

1280/2004 Malayan Banking Bhd v. Warsa Mohamed Bakar [2005] 1 ILR 262

1281/2004 Isuta Engineered Products Sdn Bhd & Ors v. Tan Eng Hock 262 [2005] 1 ILR

1314/2004 American Home Assurance Company Malaysia lwn. Sakthivel Nagalingam [2005] 1 ILR 262

1330/2004 Sasacom Sdn Bhd v. Alan Hong Boon Yaw [2005] 1 ILR 262

1331/2004 Came & Wheels East Malaysia Sdn Bhd v. Leonard Lim Yaw Chiang [2005] 1 ILR 262

1332/2004 Syn Min Kong Enterprise Sdn Bhd v. Nyarem Kako [2005] 1 ILR 263

1344/2004 Wilwan Sdn Bhd v. Dora Anthony Kuyol [2005] 1 ILR 263

1348/2004 Bukit Merah Lake Town Resort lwn. Nizam Ahmad [2005] 1 ILR 263

1369/2004 PG Engineering & Construction Sdn Bhd lwn. Quek Swee Siang [2005] 1 ILR 263

1370/2004 Polyparts (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Kok Khoon Yien [2005] 1 ILR 263

1371/2004 Koko Malaysia Sdn Bhd lwn. Mohamed Tan [2005] 1 ILR 263

1376/2004 Penang Seagate Industries (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Teh Choon Pheng [2005] 1 ILR 263

1380/2004 Kelab Menembak Pulau Pinang v. Wong Choy Hong [2005] 1 ILR 263

1381/2004 Top Condition Sdn Bhd lwn. Md Rani A Manap [2005] 1 ILR 263

1384/2004 Ole Wolff Electronics (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Cheah Eng Lai [2005] 1 ILR 263

1391/2004 Sime Darby Marketing Sdn Bhd lwn. Chew Chin Soon [2005] 1 ILR 263

1392/2004 VCC Resources Sdn Bhd lwn. Chew Kah Soon [2005] 1 ILR 263

1399/2004 Ah Yat Abalone Forum Restaurant lwn. Chow Gee Cheu & Satu Lagi [2005] 1 ILR 263

1520/2004 Bistro Americana (PJ) Sdn Bhd v. Joseph Samuel [2005] 1 ILR 263

1558/2004 Sealink Sdn Bhd lwn. Ngu Ngiik Ping [2005] 1 ILR 263

1700/2004 Telekom Malaysia Bhd v. Bidasari Juhol [2005] 1 ILR 263

1740/2004 Mastermain Enterprise Sdn Bhd v. Sabari Ahmad [2005] 1 ILR 264

1744/2004 Marudu Publisher v. Mohd Norzaidi Abdul Razak [2005] 1 ILR 264

1787/2004 Syarikat Re Morris (S) Sdn Bhd v. Susitheren Manikam [2005] 1 ILR 264

1788/2004 Karamunsing Hotel Sdn Bhd v. Dimik Damsik & Ors [2005] 1 ILR 264

1798/2004 Miri Daily News Sdn Bhd v. Chang Chiew Yong [2005] 1 ILR 264

1799/2004 Sinar Saredah Sdn Bhd v. Jimat Tadong [2005] 1 ILR 264

1800/2004 Premier Hotel v. Mohd Suffian Hasbi [2005] 1 ILR 264

1801/2004 Kim Leong Trading v. Sudiman Norudin [2005] 1 ILR 264

1802/2004 Borneo Agro Specialty Food Sdn Bhd v. Antonia Pendi & Ors [2005] 1 ILR 264

1803/2004 CB Industrial Product Sdn Bhd v. Edwin Entering [2005] 1 ILR 264

1804/2004 Best Quality Batching Sdn Bhd v. Janin Bayang [2005] 1 ILR 264

1805/2004 Rock Management Enterprise v. Jeffrey John Lises & Anor [2005] 1 ILR 264

1806/2004 Mahmood Security (M) Sdn Bhd v. Abu Bakar [2005] 1 ILR 264

1807/2004 JC Laboratory Sdn Bhd v. Alice Wee Sey Hua [2005] 1 ILR 264

1808/2004 Advantage Resources Sdn Bhd v. Lee Chee Heung [2005] 1 ILR 264

1832/2004 Viva Ct Mas (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Lee Kah Gee [2005] 1 ILR 264

1844/2004 Hotel Excelsior (M) Sdn Bhd v. Yang Sen Phaik [2005] 1 ILR 265

1845/2004 Top Glove Sdn Bhd v. Sooriyakumar Marimuthu [2005] 1 ILR 265

1846/2004 Ret-Ser Engineering Agency lwn. Ang Thian Hock [2005] 1 ILR 265

1848/2004 Merlin Cameron Highlands (Faber Group Bhd) lwn. Zalina Ahmad Rafaai [2005] 1 ILR 265

1849/2004 KCK Pharmaceutical Industries Sdn Bhd lwn. A Amirthalingam [2005] 1 ILR 265

1850/2004 Ipoh Lorry Transport Agency Sdn Bhd lwn. Cheah Weng Hoe [2005] 1 ILR 265

1851/2004 Iwabo Textile Industries Sdn Bhd lwn. Alferd Samuel [2005] 1 ILR 265

1860/2004 SUC Consortium Sdn Bhd v. Lee Joo Kit [2005] 1 ILR 265

1861/2004 Joo Seng Hong Sdn Bhd v. Yap Chung Yew [2005] 1 ILR 265

1862/2004 Stampark Management Sdn Bhd v. Kumaki Jim [2005] 1 ILR 265

1863/2004 Borneo Highway Express Sdn Bhd v. Ramlee Deno [2005] 1 ILR 265

1864/2004 Luminal Sdn Bhd v. Kimbi Ebet [2005] 1 ILR 265

1865/2004 Liew Jaw Fah v. Kana Luta & Anor [2005] 1 ILR 265

1866/2004 Sarawak Transport Co Bhd v. Koleng [2005] 1 ILR 265

1872/2004 DBE Food Processing Industries Sdn Bhd lwn. [2005] 1 ILR

Meor Zulkarnain Hassan [2005] 1 ILR 265

1875/2004 HKT (M) Sdn Bhd v. Gan Seng Kee [2005] 1 ILR 265

1876/2004 Makro Cash & Carry Distributions (M) Sdn Bhd v. Eddy Kusmizan Abd Manan & Ors [2005] 1 ILR 266

1877/2004 London Biscuits Bhd lwn. Siti Zulaiha Hanafi [2005] 1 ILR 266

1878/2004 Land Logistics Sdn Bhd lwn. Shahibul Nizam A Rahim & Satu Lagi [2005] 1 ILR 266

1879/2004 Lian Soon Siong (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Yamanni Saidu Raman [2005] 1 ILR 266

1880/2004 Hyatt Regency Johor Bahru v. Ibrahim Jaafar [2005] 1 ILR 266

1881/2004 Merit Industries Sdn Bhd lwn. Theng Sue Huey [2005] 1 ILR 266

1882/2004 Informatics Institute Ipoh v. Marjis Md Salleh [2005] 1 ILR 266

1889/2004 Ho Wah Genting Bhd v. Chen Chee Sheong [2005] 1 ILR 266

1891/2004 Jaya Jusco Stores Bhd lwn. Noor Diyana Basirah Harun [2005] 1 ILR 266

1900/2004 Amal Assurance Bhd lwn. Shahar Kamaruddin [2005] 1 ILR 266

1/2005 Diners Club (M) Sdn Bhd v. William Gohumpu [2005] 1 ILR 266

3/2005 Tang Dynasty Hotel v. Chang Vui Keong [2005] 1 ILR 266

4/2005 Syarikat Kerjasama Perkhidmatan Awam Bhd v. Datu Jack Maiks [2005] 1 ILR 266

5/2005 UMW Toyota Sdn Bhd v. Ho Meng Chee [2005] 1 ILR 266

6/2005 UMW Toyota Motor Sdn Bhd v. Rendy Lee Aik Thye [2005] 1 ILR 266

7/2005 Jaya Nets Sdn Bhd lwn. Samat Ibrahim [2005] 1 ILR 266

8/2005 Bumiputra-Commerce Finance Bhd & Anor lwn. Radzuwan Kamaruddin [2005] 1 ILR 267

10/2005 Malaysian Sheet Glass Bhd v. Hanafiah Ashari [2005] 1 ILR 267

12/2005 TH Global Services Sdn Bhd lwn. Mohammad Ishak Mansor [2005] 1 ILR 267

13/2005 Tanjung Medical Centre lwn. Thanletchumy Sangamuthu [2005] 1 ILR 267

14/2005 Jiuh Feng Enterprise (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Navamani Veerapillai [2005] 1 ILR 267

16/2005 Ube Electronics (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Amirul Farid Alwi [2005] 1 ILR 267

17/2005 Bridgestone Sporting Goods Mfg Sdn Bhd lwn. Murugan Selvarajan & Satu Lagi [2005] 1 ILR 267

18/2005 Millennium Hallmark Software Sdn Bhd lwn. Kavitha Ravinthera Rajah [2005] 1 ILR 267

19/2004 TA Securities Sdn Bhd lwn. Kartini Dalina Md Daud [2005] 1 ILR 267

20/2005 Ridzuan Hashim lwn. Masjid Darul Ehsan Subang Jaya [2005] 1 ILR 267

21/2005 Mervin Chan Yew Meng v. Chantha Corporation Sdn Bhd & Anor [2005] 1 ILR 267

22/2005 Rajaturai Mariappan v. Philips (M) Sdn Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 267

23/2005 DHT Holdings Sdn Bhd v. Nica Magunting [2005] 1 ILR 267

24/2005 T/n Th Liew Tong & Gabungan v. Chin Khiang Tsung [2005] 1 ILR 267

25/2005 Pensia Plastic Indusries Sdn Bhd lwn. Kumar Monaguran [2005] 1 ILR 267

26/2005 Merbok Mdf Sdn Bhd lwn. Mohd Thashirin Mohd Disa [2005] 1 ILR 267

27/2005 Hikari Builders Sdn Bhd v. Tan Choon Leng [2005] 1 ILR 268

28/2005 Atlas Edible Ice (PG) Sdn Bhd lwn. Mohd Basir A Rahman [2005] 1 ILR 268

30/2005 Makro Cash & Carry Distribution (M) Sdn Bhd v. Ansoral Badri Hussain [2005] 1 ILR 268

31/2005 ASN Industries Sdn Bhd lwn. Suhaidi Bahari [2005] 1 ILR 268

32/2005 Bukit Merah Laketown Resort lwn. Asmah Hasnah [2005] 1 ILR 268

33/2005 Avon Cosmetics (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Helen Thomas Thomas Joseph [2005] 1 ILR 268

34/2005 SGL Carbon Asia Pacific Sdn Bhd v. Tan Khai Poh [2005] 1 ILR 268

35/2005 James Howden (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Mohamad Hanafi Ramli & Satu Lagi [2005] 1 ILR 268

36/2005 Confucian Private Secondary School lwn. Looi Tak Kiang [2005] 1 ILR 268

37/2005 Air Asia Sdn Bhd v. Noorlailatulhijrah Azir [2005] 1 ILR 268

38/2005 Top Golden Development Sdn Bhd lwn. Chan Kong Beng [2005] 1 ILR 268

39/2005 Adampak Graphics Sdn Bhd lwn. Ooi Li li [2005] 1 ILR 268

40/2005 Lean Hock Bus Co Sdn Bhd lwn. Mat Insha Mohamud [2005] 1 ILR 268

41/2005 Associated Pan Malaysia Cement Sdn Bhd v. Cement Industry Employees’ Union [2005] 1 ILR 268

42/2005 Accoustomas Aviation Engineering (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Sathiyamoorthi Shanmugam & Anor [2005] 1 ILR 268

43/2005 Infineon Technologies (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Lim Yu Sing [2005] 1 ILR 269

44/2005 GTMH Representative Office lwn. Musnita Mustafa [2005] 1 ILR 269

45/2005 Biopower Sdn Bhd lwn. Shanmugapriya N Ramakrishnan [2005] 1 ILR 269

46/2005 West Dyna Quest Sdn Bhd lwn. Nuryati Munika Sulaiman & Satu lagi [2005] 1 ILR 269

47/2005 Sel-Jena Services Sdn Bhd lwn. Thamotharan Uthiparatai [2005] 1 ILR 269

48/2005 Burgmann (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Rafidah Mohd Nor [2005] 1 ILR 269

49/2005 Polyrak Industries Sdn Bhd lwn. Ng Hin Kee [2005] 1 ILR 269

50/2005 Unasco (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Ang Kim Ming [2005] 1 ILR 269

51/2005 Berger International Sdn Bhd v. Mohd Haire Kamit & Ors [2005] 1 ILR 269

52/2005 Felcra Bhd lwn. Zainuddin Ahmad [2005] 1 ILR 269

53/2005 Malaysia Metal Industries Sdn Bhd lwn. Choong Siew Khim [2005] 1 ILR 269

54/2005 Len Omnibus Company Bhd lwn. Zol Ahmad [2005] 1 ILR 269

55/2005 Korean Life Science Sdn Bhd v. Hong Kong Chye [2005] 1 ILR 269

56/2005 Sun Hup Lek Engineering Sdn Bhd v. Chooi Hong Loon [2005] 1 ILR 269

57/2005 Keretapi Tanah Melayu Bhd lwn. Husainy Husin [2005] 1 ILR 269

58/2005 Ngiu Kee (Kuching) Sdn Bhd v. Othman Husen & Ors [2005] 1 ILR 269

59/2005 Sistem Pakar/PPKA Sdn Bhd lwn. Hassim Khalid [2005] 1 ILR 270

60/2005 PIHP (Selangor) Bhd lwn. National Union Of Hotel, Bar & Restaurant Workers, Peninsular Malaysia [2005] 1 ILR 270

61/2005 Flextronic Manufacturing (M) Sdn Bhd v. Atick Ullah Kabir Baksh & Anor [2005] 1 ILR 270

62/2005 Flextronic Manufacturing (M) Sdn Bhd v. Shah Newaz Sarker & Ors [2005] 1 ILR 270

63/2005 Flextronic Manufacturing (M) Sdn Bhd v. Moniruzzaman & Anor [2005] 1 ILR 270

64/2005 Casio (M) Sdn Bhd v. Mohammad Nasuruddin [2005] 1 ILR 270

65/2005 Higashifuji (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Sharhimie Raini [2005] 1 ILR 270

66/2005 Innerworld Travel & Tours (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Wan Sayang Abdul Razak [2005] 1 ILR 270

67/2005 Malbartra Container Yard Sdn Bhd lwn. Md Isa Mohtar & Yang Lain [2005] 1 ILR 270

68/2005 B Braun Medical Industries Sdn Bhd lwn. Ros Abdul Rahman [2005] 1 ILR 270

70/2005 Konsortium Lordsaberket Sdn Bhd v. Mohamad Sarif Tauhid [2005] 1 ILR 270

71/2005 Zarida Zainal v. Semasa Sentral Sdn Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 270

72/2005 Remesh Kumar Kunjkrishna Pillai v. Tnt Express Worldwide (M) Sdn Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 270

73/2005 Mathavan Rathinam v. Magnificient Diagraph Sdn Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 270

74/2005 Shalini V Muthu v. Roche (M) Sdn Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 270

75/2005 Chai Swee Teik v. F&N Coca-Cola Sdn Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 271

76/2005 Azalan Yahya v. Waz Lian Leisure Management Sdn Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 271

77/2005 Abd Jamal Ahmad v. Malayan Banking Bhd [2005] 1 ILR 271

79/2005 AFM Transport Sdn Bhd lwn. Abdullah Daud [2005] 1 ILR 271

80/2005 Mdi Sdn Bhd lwn. Yap Kok Kong [2005] 1 ILR 271

81/2005 Mariam & Co lwn. Duna Mohd Isa [2005] 1 ILR 271

82/2005 Fujikura Federal Cables Sdn Bhd v. Jaafar Hamat [2005] 1 ILR 271

83/2005 Assertive Options Services Sdn Bhd lwn. Zamri Ali [2005] 1 ILR 271

84/2005 MCSB Systems (Johore) Sdn Bhd v. Ng Swee Lian & Ors [2005] 1 ILR 271

86/2005 Yeo Hiap Seng (Trading) Sdn Bhd lwn. Ramachandran Manickam [2005] 1 ILR 271

87/2005 Holiday Villa Langkawi Beach Resort lwn. Ernie Jumayla Elias [2005] 1 ILR 271

88/2005 La Cappucio Concepts Cafe Sdn Bhd lwn. Jim Paramesevam Kilasam [2005] 1 ILR 271

89/2005 Malaysian Association Of Productivity lwn. Sai Geetha Manokaran & Ors [2005] 1 ILR 271

90/2005 Pesaka Nuri (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Noor Rashidi Ahmad 271 [2005] 1 ILR

91/2005 CSR Building Materials (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. P Mg Pitchaikaran [2005] 1 ILR 271

92/2005 Syarikat Kenderaan Melayu Kelantan Bhd lwn. Mohamed Ibrahim [2005] 1 ILR 271

93/2005 Carrier Internationl Sdn Bhd lwn. Nurlia Mohd Alwai [2005] 1 ILR 272

96/2005 Selesa Health Farmm Bhd v. Sam Mat Kous [2005] 1 ILR 272

97/2005 Chunghwa Picture Tubes (M) Sdn Bhd lwn. Noruzi Abdul Rahim [2005] 1 ILR 272

99/2005 LKPP Corporation Sdn Bhd lwn. All Malayan Estates Staff Union, The [2005] 1 ILR 272

100/2005 Ardent Link Sdn Bhd lwn. Azaha Mustafa [2005] 1 ILR 272

 

CASE OF THE WEEK

BUMIPUTRA COMMERCE BANK BHD v. ABDUL KAHAR DUDI & ORS

DISMISSAL: Breach of company policies - Non adherence to procedure - Failure to comply with company's procedure leading to multi-million dollar loss - Whether company when dispensing penalty of dismissal was overly moved not by misconduct itself but by the consequences and losses arising from the breach - Whether misconduct committed was not of such a serious nature so as to warrant extreme punishment of dismissal


CLJ Bulletin
To Subscribe/Unsubscribe go to http://www.cljlaw.com/ilrsubscribefrm.asp


Copyright 1997 - 2005 CLJ Legal Network Sdn Bhd (192353 V)
Email: enquiries@cljlaw.com Phone: 603-4270-5400 Fax No : 603-4270 5401 & 603-4270 5402