Issue #38/2018
20 September 2018
|
To get the most out of this law bulletin and have full access to judgments and other materials, subscribe to CLJLaw today.
Feel free to forward this bulletin to your colleagues. Sign-up to receive this bulletin directly via email.
New This Week
|
KHAIRY JAMALUDDIN v. DATO' SERI ANWAR IBRAHIM [2018] 8 CLJ 409
COURT OF APPEAL, PUTRAJAYA
TENGKU MAIMUN TUAN MAT JCA, ZALEHA YUSOF JCA, ZABARIAH MOHD YUSOF JCA
[CIVIL APPEAL NO: W-02(W)-2061-10-2017]
01 MARCH 2018
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Appeal – Notice of appeal – Preliminary objection – Two separate orders sealed and issued by High Court – Whether separate notices of appeal should have been filed by virtue of Rules of the Court of Appeal 1994 – Whether single notice of appeal defective – Whether notice of appeal ambiguous and uncertain
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Striking out – Notice of appeal – Application for – Whether separate notices of appeal should have been filed by virtue of Rules of the Court of Appeal 1994 – Whether single notice of appeal defective – Whether notice of appeal ambiguous and uncertain
Legal Network Series
SAKTISHWARAN BATHMANATHAN lwn. DATO' AHMAD KAMAL MD SHAHID (PENGERUSI, LEMBAGA PENCEGAHAN JENAYAH) & YANG LAIN UNDANG-UNDANG PERLEMBAGAAN: Perundangan - Berperlembagaan – Kesahihan Akta Pencegahan Jenayah 1959 ('APJ') - Perlindungan kepada seseorang yang dikenakan dengan perintah pengawasan polis - Sama ada APJ adalah berperlembagaan - Sama ada peraturan 3 Peraturan-Peraturan Pencegahan Jenayah (Tatacara Lembaga Penasihat) 2014 memberikan satu peruntukan yang jelas mengenai perlindungan kepada seseorang yang dikenakan dengan perintah pengawasan polis UNDANG-UNDANG PENTADBIRAN: Semakan kehakiman - Certiorari - Perintah pengawasan polis - Perkataan-perkataan yang telah digunakan oleh Lembaga Pencegahan Jenayah ('LPJ') tidak selari dengan perkataan-perkataan di dalam s. 15(1) Akta Pencegahan Jenayah 1959 (APJ') - Sama ada perintah pengawasan telah memenuhi keperluan prosedur di bawah s. 15 APJ - Sama ada terdapat ketidakpatuhan prosedur dilakukan oleh lembaga pencegahan jenayah
|
|
PP lwn. IMAM WAHYUDIN KARJONO & SATU LAGI PROSEDUR JENAYAH: Penghukuman - Kesalahan serius - Kesalahan memberi sokongan kepada kumpulan pengganas Islamic State (IS) - Tertuduh melakukan perbuatan melemparkan bom tangan ke tempat awam yang mengakibatkan cedera parah kepada orang awam dan memusnahkan harta awam - Sama ada kesalahan yang dilakukan adalah amat serius - Sama ada hukuman berbentuk deteran perlu dijatuhkan PROSEDUR JENAYAH: Penghukuman - Peringanan - Kesalahan serius - Pengakuan bersalah selepas saksi-saksi pendakwaan memberikan keterangan - Pesalah muda - Sama ada pengakuan bersalah boleh dijadikan alasan untuk hukuman yang ringan - Sama ada tertuduh adalah cukup dewasa untuk mengetahui impak dan kesan dari kesalahan yang dilakukan - Sama ada tertuduh wajar menerima hukuman yang setimpal dengan kesalahan serius
|
|
ENERGY PERSONNEL SOLUTIONS (M) SDN BHD v. MENTERI SUMBER MANUSIA, MALAYSIA & ANOR ADMINISTRATIVE LAW: Judicial review - Certiorari - Exercise of discretionary power under s. 20(3) of Industrial Relations Act 1967 ('IRA') - Application to quash decision of Minister of Human Resource - Application to quash decision of Minister to refer 2nd respondent's representation to Industrial Court - Applicant alleged 2nd respondent was independent contractor engaged under a contract for service - Whether 2nd respondent was workman within meaning of s. 20(1) of IRA - Whether applicant and 2nd respondent had employer employee relationship - Whether Minister had acted in excess of jurisdiction
|
|
MAHENDRAN MANICKAM v. CHANG SUAN GEEN FAMILY LAW: Divorce - Decree nisi - Application to set aside consent decree nisi - Application filed before consent decree nisi could become absolute - Application to set aside filed several weeks later - Respondent wife alleged she was ill-advised by solicitors and not aware a consent decree was entered - Whether there was valid reason to set aside consent decree nisi - Whether complaint was legitimate FAMILY LAW: Divorce - Decree nisi - Application to vary terms of consent decree nisi - Maintenance for wife - Respondent wife alleged she was ill-advised by solicitors and not aware a consent decree was entered - Contents of consent decree nisi were translated, repeated and explained to respondent wife with presence of her solicitors - Whether there was any misrepresentation or mistake of fact - Whether application to vary terms ought to be granted - Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce) Act 1976, s. 83 FAMILY LAW: Divorce - Decree nisi - Jurisdictional power - Application to vary terms of consent decree nisi - Matrimonial property - Whether court has jurisdiction to vary terms entered into for matrimonial property - Whether court could deal with matrimonial property after a consent decree nisi has been entered - Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce) Act 1976, s. 76
|
|
COLIN WONG HER SHENQ v. SENG FAN TIEN & ORS CIVIL PROCEDURE: Striking out - Writ and statement of claim - Action time barred - Cause of actions of fraud, conspiracy and negligence - Six years lapsed since date of discovery - Whether plaintiff had taken a lackadaisical attitude toward his claim against defendants - Whether discovery of information in stages could postpone limitation period - Whether an action brought outside limitation period could be struck out for being frivolous, scandalous and vexatious and also an abuse of process of court
|
CLJ 2018 Volume 8 (Part 4)
COURT OF APPEAL
Khairy Jamaluddin v. Dato' Seri Anwar Ibrahim
Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, Zaleha Yusof, Zabariah Mohd Yusof JJCA
(Civil Procedure - Notice of appeal - Two separate orders sealed and issued by High Court - Whether separate notices of appeal should be filed) [2018] 8 CLJ 409 [CA]
For the appellant - Muhammad Shafee Abdullah & Sarah Abishegam; M/s Shafee & Co
For the respondent - R Sivarasa & Leela Jesuthasan; M/s Chambers of Leela J
KHK Advertising Sdn Bhd v. Siera Management Sdn Bhd (In Liquidation)
Alizatul Khair Osman, Abang Iskandar, Idrus Harun JJCA
(Company Law - Winding-up - Permanent stay of winding up order) [2018] 8 CLJ 423 [CA]
For the appellant - Khoo Guan Huat & Melissa Long; M/s Skrine
For the respondent - Mohd Izral Khairy; M/s Izral Partnership
Lau Yong Ying v. The Bank Of Punjab & Ors And Other Appeals
David Wong Dak Wah, Umi Kalthum Abdul Majid, Hasnah Mohammed Hashim JJCA
(Criminal Law - Offences - Money-laundering - Notice of seizure of land - Whether prohibited further dealings in land) [2018] 8 CLJ 446 [CA]
(Civil Appeal No: B-02(A)-900-06-2015)
For the appellant - Americk Sidhu; M/s Americk Sidhu
For the respondents - Lambert Rasa-Ratnam, Bahari Yeow Tien Hong, Muhammad Faizal Faiz Mohd Hasani & Ong Wei Shen; M/s Lee Hishammuddin Allen & Gledhill
(Civil Appeal No: B-01(A)-214-07-2015)
For the appellant - Naziah Mokhtar; State Legal Advisor, Selangor
For the respondent - Lambert Rasa-Ratnam, Bahari Yeow Tien Hong, Muhammad Faizal Faiz Mohd Hasani & Ong Wei Shen; M/s Lee Hishammuddin Allen & Gledhill
(Civil Appeal No: B-02(A)-935-06-2015)
For the appellant - Shaikh Abdul Saleem & Hajinder Singh; M/s Shaikh David Raj
For the respondent - Lambert Rasa-Ratnam, Bahari Yeow Tien Hong, Muhammad Faizal Faiz Mohd Hasani & Ong Wei Shen; M/s Lee Hishammuddin Allen & Gledhill
HIGH COURT
Abdul Wahab Hassan & Ors v. Suruhanjaya Pilihanraya Malaysia & Anor
Azizah Nawawi J
(Administrative Law - Judicial review - Application for leave - Whether exceptional circumstances shown) [2018] 8 CLJ 469 [HC]
For the applicant - Gobind Singh Deo, Michelle Ng, Joanne Chua & Jamie Lee; M/s JM Lee & Co
For the prosecution - Suzana Atan, Shamsul Bolhassan & Nik Azrin Zairin Nik Abdullah; SFCs
Azmi Ismail & Satu Lagi lwn. PP
Hassan Abdul Ghani PK
(Undang-undang Jenayah; Prosedur Jenayah - Kesalahan bawah Akta Pemuliharaan Hidupan Liar 2010 - Sabitan dan hukuman - Rayuan) [2018] 8 CLJ 477 [HC]
Bagi pihak perayu pertama - Ikmal Hisam & Noralia; T/n Ikmal Hisham & Rakan-Rakan
Bagi pihak perayu kedua - Ahmad Nizam, Falihin Kamil & Amirul Radzi; T/n Sazali & Lim
Bagi pihak responden - Munirah Zainol Abidin; TPR
Kontron Asia Pacific Design Sdn Bhd & Anor v. Quah Sin Chye & Ors And Another Appeal
Hadhariah Syed Ismail J
(Company Law; Tort - Director - Breach of fiduciary duties - Liability of directors - Conspiracy to injure - Elements of) [2018] 8 CLJ 490 [HC]
(Suit No: 22-714-2010)
For the plaintiffs - Jack Yow, Joshua & Kwong Chiew Ee; M/s Rahmat Lim & Partners
For the 1st defendant - RK Nathan & Vinod Kamalanathan; M/s RK Nathan
(Suit No: 22-710-2010)
For the plaintiff - Jack Yow, Joshua & Kwong Chiew Ee; M/s Rahmat Lim & Partners
For the defendant - Lim Aun Phung; M/s Lim, Heng & Co
SRS Sports Centre Sdn Bhd v. World Triathlon Corporation
Nordin Hassan J
(Civil Procedure; Contract - Forum conveniens - Whether Malaysia proper forum to determine dispute - Whether termination of agreement lawful) [2018] 8 CLJ 519 [HC]
For the plaintiff - M Rajan; M/s Hakem Arabi & Assocs
For the defendant - Nirmalan & Ms Joyce Sum; M/s Skrine
SUBJECT INDEX
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW
Judicial review - Certiorari - Application for leave to commence judicial review proceedings against decision of respondents - Whether available when there is alternative remedy by way of appeal - Whether there are exceptional circumstances - Elections (Registration of Electors) Regulations 2002, regs. 20(1) and 20(4)
Abdul Wahab Hassan & Ors v. Suruhanjaya Pilihanraya Malaysia & Anor
(Azizah Nawawi J) [2018] 8 CLJ 469 [HC]
CIVIL PROCEDURE
Appeal - Notice of appeal - Preliminary objection - Two separate orders sealed and issued by High Court - Whether separate notices of appeal should have been filed by virtue of Rules of the Court of Appeal 1994 - Whether single notice of appeal defective - Whether notice of appeal ambiguous and uncertain
Khairy Jamaluddin v. Dato' Seri Anwar Ibrahim
(Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, Zaleha Yusof, Zabariah Mohd Yusof JJCA) [2018] 8 CLJ 409 [CA]
Forum - Forum conveniens - Parties entered into event license agreement - Agreement terminated due to failure to rectify defaults - Agreement contained exclusive jurisdiction clause stipulating that litigation arising out of or relating to agreement would be tried in United States of America - Whether Malaysia proper forum to determine dispute and/or subject matter of claim - Whether Malaysian High Court seized with jurisdiction to hear case - Whether proceedings ought to be stayed - Rules of Court 2012, O. 12 r. 10(2) - Courts of Judicature Act 1964, s. 23(1)(a)
SRS Sports Centre Sdn Bhd v. World Triathlon Corporation
(Nordin Hassan J) [2018] 8 CLJ 519 [HC]
Striking out - Notice of appeal - Application for - Whether separate notices of appeal should have been filed by virtue of Rules of the Court of Appeal 1994 - Whether single notice of appeal defective - Whether notice of appeal ambiguous and uncertain
Khairy Jamaluddin v. Dato' Seri Anwar Ibrahim
(Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, Zaleha Yusof, Zabariah Mohd Yusof JJCA) [2018] 8 CLJ 409 [CA]
COMPANY LAW
Director - Breach of fiduciary duties - Allegation that directors involved in fictitious transactions - Failure to follow procedure set out in company's contract formation policy - Whether business carried out in irregular, abnormal and nonsensical way - Whether directors grossly negligent - Whether caused losses to company - Whether company knew of fictitious transactions - Whether directors liable to make good losses suffered by company
Kontron Asia Pacific Design Sdn Bhd & Anor v. Quah Sin Chye & Ors And Another Appeal
(Hadhariah Syed Ismail J) [2018] 8 CLJ 490 [HC]
Director - Liability of directors - Breach of fiduciary duties - Allegation that directors involved in fictitious transactions - Failure to follow procedure set out in company's contract formation policy - Whether business carried out in irregular, abnormal and nonsensical way - Whether directors grossly negligent - Whether caused losses to company - Whether company knew of fictitious transactions - Whether directors liable to make good losses suffered by company
Kontron Asia Pacific Design Sdn Bhd & Anor v. Quah Sin Chye & Ors And Another Appeal
(Hadhariah Syed Ismail J) [2018] 8 CLJ 490 [HC]
Winding-up - Petition - Permanent stay of winding up order - Whether winding up proceedings brought in bad faith and with ulterior motive of damaging plaintiff's business - Whether winding up order obtained with reasonable and probable cause - Whether there was malicious prosecution - Companies Act 1965, ss. 218 & 243
KHK Advertising Sdn Bhd v. Siera Management Sdn Bhd (In Liquidation)
(Alizatul Khair Osman, Abang Iskandar, Idrus Harun JJCA) [2018] 8 CLJ 423 [CA]
CONTRACT
Agreement - Termination - Parties entered into event license agreement - Agreement terminated due to failure to rectify defaults - Agreement contained exclusive jurisdiction clause stipulating that litigation arising out of or relating to agreement would be tried in United States of America - Whether termination lawful - Whether there was fraud and/or conspiracy - Whether Malaysia proper forum to determine dispute and/or subject matter of claim
SRS Sports Centre Sdn Bhd v. World Triathlon Corporation
(Nordin Hassan J) [2018] 8 CLJ 519 [HC]
CRIMINAL LAW
Offences - Money-laundering - Seizure - Notice - Public Prosecutor issued notice of seizure of land - Whether issuance of notice prohibited any further dealings in land - Whether any party registered as owner of land after issuance of notice of seizure only acquired defeasible title - Whether title liable to be set aside on ground it was acquired by means of void instrument - Whether notice of seizure validated by Registrar of Titles' failure to endorse terms of notice of seizure on affected land's document of title - Anti-Money Laundering and Anti-Terrorism Financing Act 2001, ss. 44, 51, 54, 56 & 57
Lau Yong Ying v. The Bank Of Punjab & Ors And Other Appeals
(David Wong Dak Wah, Umi Kalthum Abdul Majid, Hasnah Mohammed Hashim JJCA) [2018] 8 CLJ 446 [CA]
TORT
Conspiracy - Conspiracy to injure - Elements of - Breach of fiduciary duties by company directors - Allegation that directors involved in fictitious transactions - Whether business carried out in irregular, abnormal and nonsensical way - Whether resulted in loss and damages to company - Whether directors grossly negligent - Whether case of tort of conspiracy to injure established
Kontron Asia Pacific Design Sdn Bhd & Anor v. Quah Sin Chye & Ors And Another Appeal
(Hadhariah Syed Ismail J) [2018] 8 CLJ 490 [HC]
INDEKS PERKARA
PROSEDUR JENAYAH
Hukuman - Rayuan terhadap hukuman - Kesalahan melibatkan hidupan liar - Penyimpanan kepala kambing gurun dan 19 bahagian daging kambing gurun tanpa permit - Tertuduh-tertuduh dihukum penjara dua tahun dan didenda RM300,000 bagi setiap pertuduhan - Kepentingan awam - Faktor-faktor mitigasi - Sama ada munasabah untuk mengenakan denda terlalu tinggi - Sama ada hukuman denda digantikan dan dikurangkan - Sama ada hukuman penjara dikekalkan
Azmi Ismail & Satu Lagi lwn. PP
(Hassan Abdul Ghani PK) [2018] 8 CLJ 477 [HC]
UNDANG-UNDANG JENAYAH
Hidupan liar - Penyimpanan kepala kambing gurun dan 19 bahagian daging kambing gurun tanpa permit - Rayuan terhadap sabitan dan hukuman - Sama ada pertuduhan tidak sah di sisi undang-undang - Sama ada wujudnya faktor 'double jeopardy' - Elemen penyimpanan dibuktikan dengan penemuan dan rampasan hidupan liar - Sama ada kedua-dua tertuduh mempunyai niat bersama - Keterangan ikut keadaan - Sama ada membuktikan kebersalahan kedua-dua tertuduh - Sama ada kedua-dua tertuduh gagal menyangkal segala bukti dan keterangan pihak pendakwaan - Sama ada sabitan selamat - Akta Pemuliharaan Hidupan Liar 2010, s. 68 - Kanun Tatacara Jenayah, s. 376(1) - Perlembagaan Persekutuan, per. 145(3)
Azmi Ismail & Satu Lagi lwn. PP
(Hassan Abdul Ghani PK) [2018] 8 CLJ 477 [HC]
LNS Article(s)
LAND LAW - INDEFEASIBILITY: MEANING OF 'GOOD FAITH' [Read excerpt]
HENG YEE KEAT* [2018] 1 LNS(A) xciCONFLICT OF INTEREST AND THE REMOVAL OF LIQUIDATORS* [Read excerpt]
DIANA LAU ANN NA** [2018] 1 LNS(A) xcPENCEMARAN TEMPAT KEJADIAN JENAYAH [Read excerpt]
Mohd Aliffadhli Zakaria[i] Nurul Suffina Ahmad[ii] Alia Suzila Chek Pi[iii] Ramalinggam Rajamanickam[iv] [2018] 1 LNS(A) xciiAPPRAISING THE STATUTORY FRAMEWORK ON CHILD RIGHTS PROTECTION [Read excerpt]
Akinremi Funmilola*Deborah Alolo Olorunmaie** [2018] 1 LNS(A) lxxxix
CLJ Article(s)
SIASATAN KEBAKARAN FORENSIK: KEPENTINGAN DAN HALA TUJU DI MALAYSIA [Read excerpt]
TENGKU SHAHRIZAM TUAN LAH, ZALLIZA ARIP SARASWATHI RAVINDRAN* & RAMALINGGAM RAJAMANICKAM** [2018] 8 CLJ(A) xxv
Principal Acts
Number | Title | In force from | Repealing |
ACT 807 | Service Tax Act 2018 | 1 September 2018 [PU(B) 508/2018] | - |
ACT 806 | Sales Tax Act 2018 | 1 September 2018 [PU(B) 506/2018] | - |
ACT 805 | Goods and Services Tax (Repeal) Act 2018 | 1 September 2018 [PU(B) 510/2018] | - |
ACT 804 | Dental Act 2018 | Not Yet In Force | - |
ACT 803 | Anti-Fake News Act 2018 | 11 April 2018 [PU(B) 174/2018] | - |
Amending Acts
Number | Title | In force from | Principal/Amending Act No |
ACT A1572 | Free Zones (Amendment) Act 2018 | 1 September 2018 [PU(B) 512/2018] | ACT 438 |
ACT A1571 | Customs (Amendment) Act 2018 | 1 September 2018 [PU(B) 511/2018] | ACT 235 |
ACT A1570 | Sports Development (Amendment) Act 2018 | Not Yet In Force | ACT 576 |
ACT A1569 | Arbitration (Amendment) (No. 2) Act 2018 | 8 May 2018 [PU(B) 265/2018] | ACT 646 |
ACT A1568 | Fire Services (Amendment) Act 2018 | 1 September 2018 [PU(B) 505/2018] | ACT 341 |
PU(A)
Number | Title | Date of Publication | In force from | Principal/ Amending Act No |
PU(A) 236/2018 | Passports (Exemption of Visa To Citizen of The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia) Order 2018 | 12 September 2018 | 15 September 2018 | ACT 150 |
PU(A) 235/2018 | Self-Employment Social Security (Amendment of Second Schedule) Order 2018 | 6 September 2018 | 14 June 2017 | ACT 789 |
PU(A) 234/2018 | Sales Tax (Goods Exempted From Tax) (Amendment) (No. 2) Order 2018 | 6 September 2018 | 6 September 2018 | PU(A) 219/2018 |
PU(A) 233/2018 | Sales Tax (Rates of Tax) (Amendment) Order 2018 | 6 September 2018 | 6 September 2018 | PU(A) 221/2018 |
PU(A) 232/2018 | Service Tax (Imposition of Tax For Taxable Service In Respect of Designated Areas and Special Areas) (Amendment) Order 2018 | 6 September 2018 | 6 September 2018 | PU(A) 212/2018 |
PU(B)
Number | Title | Date of Publication | In force from | Principal/ Amending Act No |
PU(B) 512/2018 | Appointment of Date of Coming Into Operation | 28 August 2018 | 29 August 2018 | ACT A1572 |
PU(B) 511/2018 | Appointment of Date of Coming Into Operation | 28 August 2018 | 29 August 2018 | ACT A1571 |
PU(B) 510/2018 | Appointment of Date of Coming Into Operation | 28 August 2018 | 29 August 2018 | ACT 805 |
PU(B) 509/2018 | Appointment of Effective Date For Charging and Levying of Service Tax | 28 August 2018 | 29 August 2018 | ACT 807 |
PU(B) 508/2018 | Appointment of Date of Coming Into Operation | 28 August 2018 | 29 August 2018 | ACT 807 |
Legislation Alert
Updated
Act/Principal No. | Title | Amended by | In force from | Section amended |
ACT 789 | Self-Employment Social Security Act 2017 | PU(A) 235/2018 | 14 June 2017 | Second Schedule |
ACT 51 | Dental Act 1971 | PU(A) 229/2018 | 5 September 2018 | Second Schedule |
PU(A) 103/2017 | Customs (Prohibition of Imports) Order 2017 | PU(A) 223/2018 | 1 September 2018 | Second and Fourth Schedule |
PU(A) 102/2017 | Customs (Prohibition of Exports) Order 2017 | PU(A) 222/2018 | 1 September 2018 | Second Schedule |
PU(A) 210/2007 | Customs (Appeal Tribunal) Regulations 2007 | PU(A) 215/2018 | 1 September 2018 | Regulations 3 and 4 |
Revoked
Act/Principal No. | Title | Revoked by | In force from |
PU(A) 461/1997 | Fees (National Planetarium) Order 1997 | PU(A) 177/2018 | 30 July 2018 |
PU(A) 349/2016 | Price Control and Anti-Profiteering (Mechanism to Determine Unreasonably High Profit For Goods) Regulations 2016 | PU(A) 130/2018 | 6 June 2018 |
PU(A) 184/2013 | Ministers of the Federal Government (No. 2) Order 2013 | PU(A) 125/2018 | 10 May 2018 |
PU(A) 187/2014 | Goods and Services Tax (Imposition of Tax For Supplies in Respect of Designated Areas) Order 2014 | PU(A) 123/2018 | 1 June 2018 |
PU(A) 185/2014 | Goods and Services Tax (Application to Government) Order 2014 | PU(A) 122/2018 | 1 June 2018 |